| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 227 - Brett Lovett
Most goals: 77 - Allan La Fontaine
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Wally Naismith | 1912 | |
| Hedley Tomkins | 1913 | Number 11 in 1912 |
| Frank Lugton | 1914 | Number 32 in 1913 |
| Alex Fraser | 1914-1915 | |
| Con Kenney | 1919 | |
| Bert Chadwick | 1920-1928 | |
| Bill MacDonald | 1929-1931 | |
| Joe Kinnear | 1932 | Number 15 in 1933, 2 in 1934, 36 in 1935, 6 from 1936-1937 |
| Geoff McInnes | 1933 | Number 10 in 1932 |
| Allan La Fontaine | 1934-1942 and 1945 | |
| Denis Cordner | 1943 | Number 1 from 1948 to 1956 |
| Frank Deayton | 1943 | Number 27 in 1942 |
| Tom Bush | 1944 | Number 5 in 1942 |
| Frank Kennedy | 1946-1947 | Number 39 in 1944, 37 in 1945 |
| Greg Lourey | 1948 | Number 28 in 1950 |
| John Dorgan | 1949 | |
| Geoff McGivern | 1950-1956 | |
| Graeme Wilkinson | 1958 | |
| Ray Dawson | 1961-1963 | |
| Graeme Watson | 1964-1965 | |
| Jeff Chapman | 1966 | |
| John Comben | 1967 | |
| Kelvin Clarke | 1968-1970 | |
| Denis Clark | 1971-1975 | |
| Shane Grambeau | 1976-1979 | |
| Michael Seddon | 1980-1983 | |
| Frank Rugolo | 1986 | Number 43 from 1983 to 1984, 34 in 1985 |
| Brett Lovett | 1987-1997 | Number 50 in 1986 |
| Michael Clark | 2002 | |
| Chris Johnson | 2005-2007 | |
| Sam Blease | 2012-2014 | Number 46 in 2011 |
| Sam Frost | 2015-2019 | |
| Harley Bennell | 2020 | |
| Jake Bowey | 2021- | |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Ron Rolfe | 1960 |
AFLW
Most games: 28 - Tahlia Gillard
Most goals: 1 - Niamh McEvoy
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Ashleigh Guest | 2018 - 2019 | |
| Niamh McEvoy | 2020 - 2021 | |
| Tahlia Gillard | 2022 summer - |